So damn easy to love

10 May

by Jess

Laura: i like that beyonce does subversive stuff while doing sexy dancing with her amazing body
Jess: like gaga!
Laura: yes!
Jess: they are a perfect pair
Laura: they should get married
Jess: even though i didn’t like telephone that much
Laura: though i suppose jay z wouldn’t like that
Jess: oh who cares what he thinks
Laura: yeah, he can suck it
Jess: he can have 99 problems and a bitch is two

We didn’t have cable when I was a kid, which I thought was because it cost a lot, but was really because my mom figured I would be glued to MTV 24/7, and she didn’t like me watching all the booty-shaking vids and getting body image problems. She was right in some ways — I mostly wanted to watch The State, Beavis and Butthead, and 120 minutes, and I got much bigger body image problems from her having me on a diet all the time, but there was definitely a near-constant stream of blatant, unexamined objectification going on in most of the videos being aired.

There still would be, I assume, if MTV played videos anymore. And with the sound off, Beyonce’s latest would fit right into that tradition. The Divine Miss B never once puts on pants with anything that can accurately be called an “inseam,” and spends much of the video either gyrating, weeping, cooking, or scrubbing. By those lights, not a very feminist moment, by golly. But… ok, watch the thing:

To me, the lyrics here throw the visuals into sharp, subversive relief. She sings about “making me so damn easy to love” by being beautiful and classy and dirty in the bedroom, sure, but the explicit conclusion is: “I’m clearly lovable, so what the hell is YOUR problem?” And in light of that narrative — “I’ve done everything that’s supposed to make a woman desirable, and you still don’t love me, so in the end I’m terrific and you’re a chump” — you start seeing the rictus of a smile while she’s doing her hula girl moves. The trappings of femininity are all over the video, but they’re cast as fruitless attempts to ensnare a guy who doesn’t appreciate either canonical desirable-woman accoutrements (“I got beauty, I got class / I got style, and I got ass”) or intelligence and independence (“Don’t have to ask no one to help me out / … / Keep my head in them books, I’m sharp”).

Is it a little maddening that the bulk of the song is still a checklist of feminine ideals? Is it stone cold infuriating that a woman with pipes like Beyonce’s still has to take her kit off to be a big star? You bet it is. There’s only so subversive you can get while still getting widespread acclaim — Beyonce is a woman of color, which breaks the usual bombshell mode, but she’s still thin, beautiful, light-skinned, and European-featured, and she’s still making it clear that she scrubs the floor in hotpants for the sake of her man. But what’s new here is that it’s a song about what’s wrong with the man that he doesn’t appreciate her. There is no point at which she wonders if she ought to be more beautiful, more obedient, more scantily dressed. If it’s not quite a feminist song, it’s worlds more feminist than most of what’s out there at this level of fame. And that very fact makes it subversive — it sneaks a new idea (that the femininity checklist won’t get you loved, and that the problem might be him and not you) into an antifeminist culture.

Okay, I’m talking like a big thinky blogger, but full disclosure: my reactions to this video are not entirely intellectual. The first thing I said to Laura when she showed it to me was “I wish this had come out eight years ago” — that is, when I was in a relationship with a guy who not only didn’t appreciate me but essentially exploited me. Not incidentally, he also made me feel like there was something deeply wrong with me for not being both more satisfying and more satisfied. It was in his interest for me to never think to answer “why don’t you love me?” with “maybe you’re just plain dumb” — that wasn’t going to get his back rubbed, his apartment cleaned, or his dick sucked. He kept me from making the connection by keeping the focus on me not being beautiful, smart, obedient, or levelheaded enough to keep him happy. (Oh, and also by making me feel, and basically telling me I was, more or less insane.)

So I’m not just having a strict feminist reaction here — by those lights, there’s not a pop song in the world that passes. I’m also thinking about what this song would have done for me when I was buying so hard into the hype. Hortense at Jezebel just wrote a terrific post about how much Tragic Kingdom buoyed her out of her angst as a teenager — I can’t say I feel that way about No Doubt, although I was also 15 when the album dropped, but I definitely understand how an anthem can be the thread you follow out of a very dark place. I remember how I felt about Lush’s “Ladykillers” when I was a teenager (“when he’s nice to me, he’s just nice to himself”) and about the Golden Palominos’ “I’m Not Sorry” after a different emotionally abusive relationship — that “oh!” moment, that sense of a second pair of eyes opening wide inside your head. I could see this song waking women up and guiding them away from what’s destroying them.

This guy hasn’t even lived in the same country as me in five years, and I still wonder what I could have changed that would have made him love me. Last night I went to a coffee shop a few blocks from where he used to live, to watch my exceptionally beautiful and talented friend Acacia play a show. Acacia is a very impressive person, both naturally gifted and extremely skilled at her craft — plus she’s very pretty, plus she has in the past been very well-endowed in the particular areas this guy fancied (I mean, talent also, but mostly I’m talking about boobs here). So at about the point of drunkenness where I get maudlin, I was sitting there watching her rock the fuck out on a Patty Griffin song and thinking “what if I’d just been this good at something, what if I’d only looked like her? What if I’d basically tried this whole relationship, only as Cacie?” Can I repeat that this started in fucking 2002, and I still think this way after two cocktails? The answer I came up with was “well, in that case he would have just been a complete dick to Cacie, and I could never tolerate that.” But the only reason I could get to that conclusion was that he has been gone for five years (and I am in therapy). The right kickass anthem might have jump-started the process, maybe even given me a clue back when he still lived here and I really needed it. And this one, as ubiquitous as it is, could never have flown under my radar.

So really for me, the question of whether this song succeeds from a feminist perspective is peripheral to the question of whether it can actually help women. The fact that Beyonce’s success is built on her adherence to beauty ideals and general semi-nakedness as much as on her talent is important — of course it is. The fact that women’s worth still gets boiled down to “omg boobies!” is a big part of why I bother writing about shit in the first place. But my analysis of this song is based first and foremost on the image in my head of some lost and despondent 22-year-old belting it alone in her car while she drives away at 3 am from the apartment of a man who only wants her for what he can get from her. “There’s nothing not to love about me. There’s nothing not to need about me. Maybe you’re just not the one… or maybe you’re just plain dumb.”

Advertisements

4 Responses to “So damn easy to love”

  1. Laura May 10, 2010 at 10:45 am #

    but I definitely understand how an anthem can be the thread you follow out of a very dark place

    This is why Lady Gaga and Beyonce give me great hope about pop music, not just because of their lyrics but also because of their sexy/subversive images. I can’t imagine what it would have been like for me as a teenager to see (to take just one example) that magazine cover with Gaga wearing leather pants and a huge strap-on and also showing her tits. My teenage mind would have fucking exploded in the best way possible.

  2. Elysia May 10, 2010 at 11:21 pm #

    Ha Laura totally beat me to it but…

    but I definitely understand how an anthem can be the thread you follow out of a very dark place

    I was just feeling something like this listening to The Supremes this weekend. And I think that this is the kind of smart reason I would have wanted to use several times to explain why it’s important that Angry Young Women get swept into the Pop Starlet spotlight. Alanis Morrissette comes to mind. Ditto Avril Levigne. Maybe the oft-replayed songs aren’t exactly feminist, but they clearly say, “You know what? I’m not the problem here!”

  3. Jess May 10, 2010 at 11:32 pm #

    And, it just now occurs to me, Gloria Gaynor, whose manifesto I did have as an anthem and it truly did help me. (But by the time of this relationship I was far enough away from the sisterhood of college that I guess I forgot it. Maybe all young women need to be issued mix tapes as soon as they hit adolescence.)

    I feel like Alanis and to a lesser extent Avril — and certainly the mom of them all, Liz Phair — get relegated to “alternative” status even as they hit stardom. Beyonce’s fame is qualitatively different even if not quantitatively, because there’s no part of her image that’s saying “I’m being edgy and subversive here.” But maybe I’m reverse-engineering the history of music to fit my thesis! I mean, certainly the strong-woman anthem predates the existence of the alterna-chick image by decades. I just really appreciate having it occasionally ferried back into the public consciousness by someone whose semiotics say “I, and by extension these sentiments, belong here.”

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. How Sassy didn’t change my life « Birthday Bread Horse - May 13, 2010

    […] just realized that this is my second post for this blog where I wonder how my life would have differed if I’d had the right light to […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: